Allen
Granbery Thurman
By Albert Lee ThurmanIn the long list of
illustrious names, claimed by the commonwealth of Ohio,
may be enrolled that of Allen Granbery Thurman. Born
at Lynchurg, Virginia, on the 13th of November, 1813, he
was, when but six years old, brought by his parents to
Ohio, and from that time until the day of his death, was
numbered among her most loyal and devoted sons. As
has been said of him, he was "the product of our sturdy
pioneer days and our American civilization." On both
sides of his house flowed the blood that caused him to
become famous, above all things, for his sterling honesty
and integrity. His father, Pleasant Thurman, was a
Methodist minister. His mother, Mary Allen Thurman,
was one of the daughters of Nathaniel Allen, a nephew of
Joseph Hewes, one of the signers of the Declaration of
Independence.
On moving to Ohio, his parents settled in Chillicothe,
at that time the most flourishing town in the State.
There, his boyhood days were spent, there, was laid the
foundation of those habits of industry and of study, that
were always among his most marked characteristics.
His parents, intellectual and cultured, devoted their time
and attention to his education, and so particular was his
mother in this regard, that long after her death, and when
he had become the recipient of many honors at the hands of
his fellow citizens, he was herd to say: "I owe more
to my mother than to any other preceptor I ever had."
He attended the public school in Chillicothe, and
afterwards, what was known as the Academy, a preparatory
school for colleges. It is related that after
graduating from the Academy, other members of his class
departed for the East to attend college, while, he, owning
to the financial inability of his parents to assume the
burden, was compelled to remain at home; that he bade them
good bye with a brave heart and cheerful countenance, but
after the state had departed he sought the solitude of the
graveyard, and there gave vent to his bitter
disappointment in a flood of tears. But that
indomitable courage and unconquerable will that ever
characterized his life, and made him the great student that
he was, soon asserted itself, the disappointment was
forgotten in the determination to study by and for
himself. In order to acquire the facilities and
means for obtaining larger educational advantages, he
taught at a country school, and during the vacations
devoted his time to surveying. His liking for
mathematics was most marked, and in after years, when he
had grown old and gray, his grandchildren would take their
puzzling problems to him, sure of a kindly reception, the
correct answer, and the reasons therefor.
He early developed a fondness for the study of law, and
as soon as his circumstances would allow, began the study
in the office of his uncle, William Allen, and there
devoted himself so thoroughly and so conscientiously to
his work as to make almost certain the great success that
afterwards attended him in his profession.
At this time, he also became active in politics,
espousing the cause of the Democratic party, and soon
thereafter received his first political honor, being
appointed by Gov. Lucas as his private secretary. He
continued his study under the tutelage of Judge Noah
Swayne, afterwards a member of the Supreme Court of the
United States, and, in 1835, was admitted to the bar in
Ohio, at that time famous for its for its learning and
ability. Forming a partnership with his uncle,
William Allen, in Chillicothe, his success was most
marked, and until he became a member of the Supreme Court
of Ohio, he was employed in practically all of the
important litigation in that part of the State.
On the 14th day of November, 1844, he married Mary
Allen Tompkins, a daughter of John Dun, a prominent
Kentuckian. Sharing equally the sorrows, the
disappointments and the honors, they were in old age as in
youth, "lovers whose affection broadened and strengthened
as the years rolled on." Her influence, like that of
his mother, strengthened the noble traits of his character
and made all the more certain his great success. Of
this union there were born three daughters and one son.
Mrs. Thurman died in 1891, but a few years before her
husband.
Though most active in politics, it was not until 1844
that he allowed himself to become a candidate for any
political office. In the Polk-Clay campaign of that
year, he was the Democratic nominee for Congress from the
Chillicothe District, and after a most spirited campaign
was elected by a handsome majority. At this time the
United States was engaged in the war with Mexico, and Mr.
Thurman was found among the most ardent supporters of the
Administration in the conduct of that war. The great
dispute between the North and the South was then becoming
more heated, and though allied with the Democratic party
and opposing any change or interference with the Missouri
Compromise, Mr. Thurman, with nearly all of the other
Democratic members of the House from the North, voted for
the Wilmot Proviso. For this action they were
severely criticised by the Southern members, and in reply
to those criticisms, he delivered a speech, in 1874, in
which, and especially in the closing paragraphs thereof,
he set forth with remarkable power, clearness and force,
the reasons for the position taken by himself and his
Northern colleagues. As he said "Why, then, does the
North insist upon opposing the extension of slave
territory? I answer, because, first, as the
municipal legislature of the territories, it is the duty of
Congress to promote their interests. The people of
the free States think, whether erroneously or not, that is
for the interest of any country that slavery be
prohibited, and thinking so, we as the legislative power
over the territories, deem it our duty, where it can be
done without too great a sacrifice, to exclude slavery
from them. Another reason: That Congress is the
National legislature, and therefore, must look to the
National interest; and as the strength and prosperity of
the Nation is composed of the strength and prosperity of
its parts, it is the duty of Congress, no insuperable
object standing in the way, to pursue such a course of
policy as shall strengthen, in the greatest degree, the
United States; and believing that free territory would be
more populous, wealthy, abundant in resources, and in
every thing that makes a great nation, it is for the
National interests to have as much free territory as
possible, compatible with the existence of the Union.
The third reason is, that in the opinion of the North, it
is inconsistent with the genius of our institutions, and
injurious to the character of the United States, to extend
slavery. Where it exists, let it exist, says the
North, but do not extend it by the action of the general
Government, and convert what is now free, into slave
territory."
Notwithstanding this position, he was, during the war
of the succession, severely criticised and was accused of
being in sympathy with the Southern cause. All such
criticisms, and such accusations were without foundation.
As he afterwards said "I did all I could to help preserve
the Union without a war, but after it began I thought
there was but one thing to do, and that was to fight it
out. I, therefore, sustained all constitutional
measures that tended, in my judgment, to put down the
Rebellion. I never believed in the doctrine of
Sucession."
At the close of his Congressional term he
declined a renomination, and resumed the practice of law
in Chillicothe. In 1851, the new Constitution of
Ohio went into effect, and Mr. Thurman was elected one of
the Judges of the Supreme Court, as reorganized.
Here is great powers of logic, concentration and analysis
soon brought him into the greatest prominence. The
decisions rendered by him are looked to as full of wisdom
and of learning, and among the most able and valuable that
have ever been rendered from any Bench. Had his
career closed with his retirement from the Supreme Court,
his fame would still, by reason of these decisions, have
been none the less great. His term ended in 1856,
and he once more resumed the practice of the law, this
time in Columbus. He did not again enter actively
into politics until 1867, when he became the Democratic
nominee for Governor of Ohio. The previous campaign
had been won by the Republican party by a majority of over
40,000 but, notwithstanding this fact. Mr. Thurman
conducted his canvass most vigorously and succeeded in
bringing about a drawn battle, for though he himself was
defeated by less than 3,000, the Democratic party
succeeded in carrying the legislature. It was the
duty of that body to elect the successor of Senator
Wade
to the United States Senate, and Mr. Thurman was chosen as
that successor. His services in the Senate of the
United States covered a period of twelve years, being
succeeded in 1880 by John Sherman. During all of
that time he was a member of the Judiciary Committee, and
his services, there rendered, were important and valuable.
To Describe the high position taken by him in the Senate,
and the esteem in which he was held by his colleagues,
I quote from Senator James G. Blaine in his "Twenty Years
in Congress." There he says "Mr. Thurman's rank in
the Senate was established from the day he took his seat,
and was never lowered during the period of his service.
He was an admirably disciplined debater, fair in the
method of his statement, logical in his argument, honest
in his conclusions. He had no trick in discussion,
no catch phrases to secure attention, but was always
direct and manly. His retirement from the Senate was
a severe loss to his party, a loss indeed to the body."
There he met Edmund, Evarts, Saulsbury,
Bayard, Chandler,
Carpenter, Schurz, Cameron, Conkling and the others of
those great men whose task was the safe guilding of the
Government through the stormy days of the Reconstruction.
There it was that was paid him, by Senator Conkling of New
York, the famous, and probably, the most graceful
compliment ever paid by one public man to another.
During a legal argument, he repeatedly turned towards
Senator Thurman, as if addressing him. Finally the
latter asked "Does the Senator from New York expect me to
answer him every time he turns to me?" Conkling,
after a moment's hesitation, replied, "When I speak of the
law, I turn to the Senator from Ohio, as the Mussulman
turns toward Mecca. I turn to him as I do to the
English common law as the world's most copious fountain of
human jurisprudence."
Mr. Thurman was chosen as one of the Electoral
Commission for the settling of the controversy arising out
of the Hayes-Tilden campaign, in 1876, and as a member of
the Commission earnestly and steadfastly supported the
claims of Mr. Tilden.
But among the many great services rendered by him while
in the United States Senate, probably the greatest was
that in connection with the Government's claims against
the Pacific Railroads. These corporation had
received from the Government many and valuable franchises
and rights upon certain terms and conditions, which they
afterwards refused to comply with. Mr. Thurman
introduced a bill in the Senate, the purpose of which was
to compel the Pacific corporations to fulfill their
obligations to the Government. He succeeded in
effecting the passage of this bill, since known as the
"Thurman Act," against a combined and powerful opposition,
with the result that the corporations were compelled to
comply with the conditions under which their franchises
and rights were given, and saving the Federal Treasury
many millions of dollars.
He was a candidate for the nomination for the
Presidency in the National Democratic Conventions of 1876,
1880 and 1884.
After his retirement from the Senate, and during the
administration of President Garfield, Mr. Thurman was
appointed a member of the Paris Monetary Conference.
Several years later he was employed by the Government
as counsel in the famous Bell Telephone litigation, and in
that capacity rendered most able and valuable services.
In 1888, he was named for the Vice Presidency, and
though old in years, entered vigorously into the campaign,
making a number of speeches in New York, Pennsylvania,
Ohio, Michigan, Indiana and Illinois. At the ensuing
election the party was defeated, and this defeat marked
the end of his political career.
In the Spring of 1888, he was appointed by the Court to
assist in the prosecution of parties charged with having
altered the election tally sheets in Franklin County,
Ohio. The accused were all of the Democratic party
but this did not cause him to hesitate in accepting the
appointment. The closing words of his argument in
that case show how well he loved the party that had so
honored him, how devoted he was to its principles, how
anxious he was to see it succeed, but only to succeed
through justice and right. These were his words:
"But I do want this party, to which I have belonged for
more than sixty years, for I began when I was a child;
this party which has done so much for me, and which I have
conscientiously believed in; which has its faults, as all
parties, have had their faults; which has been wrong
sometimes, as all parties have been wrong; but in which I
have believed, to which has been wrong sometimes, as all
parties have been wrong; but in which I have believed, to
which my faith has been pledged and has been kept - I do
want that party, in the going down of the sum of my life,
when I shall look for the last time abroad on earth, I do
want to see that party still standing, still respected,
still honored and still deserving the good will and
kindness and support of all my fellow beings."
This was his last public appearance, and at its close
he retired to the privacy of his home, spending the
remaining days with his family and among his books.
He died on the 12th day of December, 1895, after a
short illness, honored, respected and loved by all. |